Setting The Sybil Ludington Story Straight
By Vincent T. Dacquino
The story of Sybil Ludington is pretty straightforward. On April 26, 1777, A sixteen year old girl from Dutchess County, NY, took a 40 mile death-defying ride on horseback through the countryside to muster her father’s troops for a battle in Danbury, Connecticut. Her father was a colonel in the militia and was in command of approximately 400 men. When a messenger arrived at the Ludington house at 9 o’clock on a Sunday night to seek his help, there was no one to send to arouse the men and get them to the parade grounds to prepare for battle. His men were farmers and merchants and likely asleep. What was he to do? General Tryon of the British army had attacked Danbury with 2000 troops and was killing colonists and burning their homes. And so Sybil, who knew the whereabouts of her father’s men from previous trips to their homes, went out into the night on horseback in the pouring rain, when she finally returned exhausted at daybreak her father and his men were off to battle. Unfortunately, the battles that ensued included the loss of a heroic American army general, David Wooster.
As interesting as that story is, what is even more interesting is the history of Sybil’s history. How and when did we hear about this heroic act? Fortunately today, the paper trail is quite clear.
In 1854, a group of Masons from Danbury, Connecticut, planned a commemoration of a statue to honor David Wooster. Charles Henry Ludington, grandson of Colonel Ludington and nephew to Sybil, heard of this event and immediately wrote a letter to the committee suggesting that his aunt and grandfather be mentioned since they were very much involved in that battle. The letter explicitly mentioned Sybil’s daring ride. That letter exists in the New York Historical Library in New York City. The Ludingtons were not mentioned at the event, but Charles did not give up fighting. Charles joined forces with his cousin, Lewis S. Patrick, to get his grandfather and aunt the credit they deserved. They wrote letters to their relatives to learn more of their family history and created a form to be used in hopes of documenting the exploits of their ancestors. One of the return letters was written by Charles’s sister, Laura Ann Ludington Hustis, explicitly recounting the story of Sybil’s ride as it was told to her by her grandmother, Abigail Ludington (Sybil’ s mother) when Laura was ten years old. We remember that Sybil’s mother was present on the night of Sybil’s ride. Copies of that letter and the family form are also available at the New York Historical Society Library as The Ludington Family Papers Ms. 2962 New-York Historical Society’s Research Library. Collection donated by Jane Ludington in 2015) Jane Ludington is the great ancestral niece of the Colonel’s grandson, Charles Henry Ludington, and the wife of Charles Townsend Ludington Jr. The documents were passed down through the generations and found in her summer house in Connecticut.
In 1880, Martha Lamb, a respected historian, included the story of Sybil and her father in a volume of her History of the Origins of New York City. (History of the City of New York: It’s Origin and Rise and Progress. Vol. 2.) A letter to Martha Lamb from Charles confirms him as the source for her information although he was not named as the source in her article. While her article was a huge step in getting Sybil’s story out, it did not get the attention that the cousins were hoping for.
In 1907, historian Lewis S. Patrick, great grandson of Colonel Ludington through the Colonel’s brother Frederick, published a story in The Connecticut Journal, (Secret Service of the American Revolution, 11, No. 2, 1907) detailing the life of his great grandfather and great aunt Sybil. Almost simultaneously, Charles and his sister Lavinia, grandchildren through the Colonel’s brother Lewis, hired Willis Fletcher Johnson, a well-known author and historian, to write a biography on their grandfather and supplied him with the family correspondence and documents. (Colonel Heny Ludington: A Memoir. New York 1907) The book got new attention for Sybil and her father, but it was not until 1934 that through the influence of the Daughters of the American Revolution and others, signs were put along “the probable route” of Sybil’s ride. ( New York Herald Tribune, Sunday, Sept 9, 1934)
By 1940 another notch was cut into Sybil’s history. A famed poet, Berton Braley, author of over 9 thousand poems on Americans, created a poem in Sybil’s honor. (Sybil Ludington’s Ride. Sunday Star. This Week Magazine. Washinton D.C. April 14, 1940.) It is believed that this is the poem that was read by the famed sculptor Anna Hyatt Huntington inspiring her to create a life-sized statue of Sybil dedicated in her honor on June 3, 1961. The statue is located on Sybil’s route at the shore of Lake Gleneida in Carmel, New York. Several smaller replicas of the statue were also created for sites in Danbury and Washington, DC.
By 1975, Sybil got the attention of the United States Postal Service with a stamp and celebration that declared her “A Contributor to the Cause.” Seventy-five thousand stamps were sold on the day of the celebration.
In 1997, I discovered Sybil and created a biography (The Call to Arms, Purple Mountain Press, 2000. It addressed a multitude of errors in Sybil’s personal life written by various authors. The book was well received but some people continued to question whether Sybil actually took the ride. They stated early objections from the internet falsely claiming that the first mention of the ride was in 1907, too long after the ride to be verified. We know now that they were incorrect. Others agreed that the first mention was 1880, but said Martha Lamb offered no reliable sources for her article making the information questionable. We now have letters indicating her source as Sybil’s nephew, a dedicated family researcher who mentioned her ride as early as 1854. Still others lament that Sybil never mentioned her ride in any of her 77 years of life. That isn’t a surprise. Many true heroes don’t recognize their actions as heroic. They simply do what must be done. Furthermore, her father’s life was in constant danger from the British, Loyalists, Cowboys and Skinners. News of her ride could have meant danger to her as well. And why didn’t early historians write about her ride? They simply didn’t know about it for all of the above reasons. Historic works often cited as having ignored Sybil’s ride predate Lamb’s mention of it in her book. No military pension records mention Sybil’s ride because women were not allowed to be soldiers; they were only allowed to do the duties of one. Pension records from soldiers were generally documentation from the soldier or his family about the soldier’s own involvement in a battle, not about the messenger who called him out to it, regardless of how dangerous that may have been.
By 2019, I was able to release a new book on Sybil Ludington, Patriot Hero of the Hudson Valley with History Press which included information from the “lost” family papers.
Information on historical events and heroes from the 1700’s is very difficult to locate and prove. Vital information like births and deaths and marriages were often scribbled into bibles and thus became history. Family history. Many great deeds by Americans, especially during the American Revolution, and especially by women and children, will never be known because their deeds were never recorded or talked about beyond their generation. Charles Ludington, Lewis S. Patrick, Martha Lamb, Willis Fletcher Johnson, Berton Braley and I would like readers to remember the courage and determination of at least one young female hero from 1777 who in taking a dangerous ride for freedom, became an important “contributor to the cause.” Reading for the truth is a must. Readers are definitely leaders— and writers are definitely fighters, fighting for the right to be heard. Hear this: On April 26, 1777, 16 year old Sybil Ludington did take a death-defying ride that earned her a rightful place in American history.